The Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) is set to transform how companies report on their sustainability efforts, marking a significant leap forward in corporate accountability.
Adopted by the European Commission in 2022, it builds upon and replaces the Non-Financial Reporting Directive (NFRD). It addresses the limitations of its predecessor by expanding its scope and enhancing reporting requirements. At its core, the CSRD aims to promote transparency and accountability in sustainability reporting across the European Union.
This directive isn’t just another regulatory hurdle; it’s designed to drive meaningful change in corporate behavior. The CSRD aligns business practices with the EU’s sustainability goals and the global push towards a more responsible economy.
In this article, we’ll explore the CSRD’s key aspects, including its requirements, scope, and potential impact. We’ll also examine how it compares to other sustainability initiatives and discuss the challenges and opportunities it presents for businesses.
Key objectives of the CSRD
At its core, the CSRD aims to standardize and enhance the quality of sustainability information disclosed by companies, making it more comparable and reliable for stakeholders.
Under the CSRD, companies must report on a wide range of environmental, social, and governance (ESG) matters. This includes detailed information on climate change impacts, emissions reduction strategies, and human rights practices throughout their value chains.
The directive introduces European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS), developed by the European Financial Reporting Advisory Group (EFRAG), to ensure consistency and comparability in reporting.
By mandating more comprehensive sustainability reporting requirements, the CSRD aims to:
- Increase transparency and accountability.
- Facilitate better-informed investment decisions.
- Drive corporate sustainability efforts.
- Support the transition to a sustainable economy.
These enhanced disclosures will provide stakeholders, including investors, customers, and employees, with a clearer picture of a company’s sustainability performance and risks.
Understanding the CRSD standards
The CSRD introduces comprehensive standards for sustainability reporting to ensure consistency, transparency, and accountability across companies. Below are key aspects of these standards.
Double materiality
Double materiality is a fundamental concept within the CSRD reporting framework, representing a significant evolution in sustainability reporting. This principle requires companies to consider and report on two distinct perspectives:
- Financial materiality: How sustainability issues impact the company’s financial performance, position, and development.
- Environmental and social materiality: How the company’s activities affect the environment and society.
In practice, this means that companies must conduct a double materiality assessment to identify and prioritize sustainability matters that are material from both financial and impact perspectives.
For instance, a company might need to report on how climate risks affect its business model and financial stability, as well as how its operations contribute to climate change through greenhouse gas emissions.
European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS)
The CSRD introduces the European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS). The ESRS standards provide a framework for companies to report on sustainability matters consistently and comparably. The ESRS covers various aspects, including climate change, environmental protection, social responsibility, and governance practices.
Comprehensive ESG reporting
Under the CSRD, companies are required to provide detailed information on a wide range of environmental, social, and governance (ESG) matters. This includes data on climate change impacts, emissions reduction strategies, human rights practices, and more. Such detailed reporting ensures that stakeholders have access to comprehensive and reliable sustainability information.
Target metrics and transition plans
Companies must share their sustainability targets, progress toward achieving them, and how those targets support a transition to a sustainable economy and achieving net-zero emissions by 2050, as EU laws require.
Value and supply chains
Companies must disclose their due diligence process for identifying and mitigating the social and environmental impacts in their value chains and supply chains. This comprehensive approach helps stakeholders understand the full scope of a company’s sustainability efforts and risks.
Third-party auditing
The CSRD requires a third party to audit and assure the sustainability information and data included in the report. Initially, compliance will require the auditor to provide limited assurance, based primarily on the organization’s own statements.
However, within the next three years, the CSRD will introduce a requirement for reasonable assurance, relying on the auditor’s examination and understanding of the organization’s operations, processes, and controls.
Who needs to comply?
While the directive primarily targets EU-based companies, its reach extends to certain non-EU companies with significant operations in the EU. The implementation of CSRD compliance is phased, allowing different categories of businesses to adapt over time.
- Large EU companies and undertakings that meet at least two of the following criteria: More than 250 employees, more than €40 million in net turnover, and more than €20 million in total assets;
- All companies listed on EU-regulated markets, except listed micro-enterprises;
- Non-EU companies with significant EU presence, meaning they either have EU turnover exceeding €150 million or at least one subsidiary or branch in the EU;
- Small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) listed on EU-regulated markets (with simplified reporting requirements);
While parent companies are generally responsible for reporting consolidated information, subsidiaries may be exempt if their sustainability information is included in the parent company’s consolidated report.
CSRD reporting requirements
Companies must now include a dedicated sustainability section in their management report, covering a wide range of environmental, social, and governance topics.
Key reporting areas include:
- Climate-related information aligned with the EU Taxonomy
- Environmental factors beyond climate, such as biodiversity and ecosystems
- Social and human rights matters
- Governance practices and business ethics
- Sustainability risks and opportunities
- Due diligence processes
- Targets and progress toward sustainability goals
- Impacts along the value chain
The standards also include sector-specific requirements, recognizing that different industries face unique sustainability challenges.
How to prepare for CSRD compliance
Early preparation is crucial, as meeting CSRD requirements may require significant changes to existing sustainability data collection and reporting processes. To effectively prepare for CSRD compliance, companies should consider the following steps:
Conduct a gap analysis
Identify the differences between your current sustainability reporting practices and the new CSRD standards. This analysis will highlight areas that need improvement or adjustment to meet compliance requirements.
Establish cross-functional teams
Form teams with members from various departments to ensure a comprehensive approach to sustainability reporting. These teams will coordinate efforts and manage the reporting process, ensuring that all aspects of the CSRD are addressed effectively.
Invest in data systems
Implement advanced systems for collecting and managing sustainability data to ensure accuracy and reliability. These systems will support the detailed reporting required by the CSRD.
Engage with stakeholders
Communicate with stakeholders, including investors, customers, and employees, to determine what sustainability information is most valuable to them. Their input will guide your reporting efforts and ensure relevance.
Develop a materiality assessment
Create a process to assess and prioritize sustainability issues based on their financial, environmental, and social impacts. This will help identify key areas for reporting under the CSRD framework.
Train staff on reporting mandates
Educate employees about the new CSRD requirements and the broader concepts of sustainability. Training will ensure that everyone involved understands their roles and responsibilities in the reporting process.
Seek external expertise
Hire consultants or external experts to guide you through the initial stages of CSRD compliance, especially for first-time reporting. Their experience can help streamline the process and ensure that your reports meet all necessary standards.
How sustainability reporting impacts businesses and stakeholders
Businesses may need to invest more in data collection and reporting processes but could also benefit from improved sustainability performance and risk management. Companies that embrace CSRD requirements may find themselves better positioned to attract sustainable investments and enhance their reputation.
Investors benefit from more comprehensive and comparable sustainability data, enabling better-informed decision-making. The standardized reporting framework facilitates easier comparison of companies’ sustainability performance across sectors and EU member states.
Employees and consumers gain greater insight into companies’ social responsibility initiatives and environmental impacts. This transparency can influence employment choices and consumer behavior, potentially rewarding companies with strong sustainability practices.
Supply chain partners may face increased scrutiny as companies report on their entire value chain, potentially leading to more sustainable business practices throughout the supply network.
Comparing the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive to other sustainability initiatives
The CSRD is a cornerstone of the EU’s broader sustainability agenda, complementing and enhancing existing initiatives. It aligns closely with the European Green Deal, supporting the EU’s ambition to become climate-neutral by 2050.
Its report requirements go beyond those of many national laws, setting a new standard for sustainability disclosure across the EU. By harmonizing reporting practices, it facilitates better comparability and transparency, supporting informed decision-making by investors and other stakeholders.
CSRD vs. SFDR
While both the CSRD and Sustainable Finance Disclosures Regulation (SFDR) are part of the EU’s sustainable finance framework, they have distinct scopes and targets:
Scope
- CSRD applies to a broad range of large companies and listed SMEs.
- SFDR focuses on financial market participants and financial advisers.
Objectives
- CSRD enhances corporate sustainability reporting.
- SFDR improves transparency in the financial services sector regarding sustainability risks and adverse impacts.
Disclosure focus
- CSRD covers environmental, social, and governance aspects.
- SFDR requires disclosures on how sustainability risks are integrated into investment decisions and advice.
Despite these differences, the CSRD and SFDR are designed to work together, creating a more transparent and sustainable financial ecosystem in the EU.
CSRD vs. TCFD
The CSRD and the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD) share the common goal of improving climate-related financial disclosures, but they differ in several key aspects:
Geographic scope
- CSRD reporting is mandatory for applicable companies in the EU.
- TCFD is a voluntary, global framework.
Coverage
- CSRD requires comprehensive sustainability reporting, including but not limited to climate issues.
- TCFD is focused specifically on climate-related financial risks and opportunities.
Legal status
- CSRD is a legally binding directive.
- TCFD offers voluntary recommendations.
The CSRD incorporates many TCFD recommendations, particularly in its climate-related disclosure requirements. This alignment ensures that companies complying with CSRD will also largely meet TCFD recommendations, facilitating global comparability of climate-related disclosures.
Sustainability reporting benefits
The CSRD could revolutionize sustainability reporting in Europe and potentially influence global practices. As companies adapt to these new requirements, we can expect to see:
- Improved data quality and comparability. Standardized reporting will enable better benchmarking and analysis of corporate sustainability performance.
- Increased innovation in sustainable business practices. Enhanced transparency may drive companies to improve their sustainability initiatives to remain competitive.
- Greater integration of sustainability into business strategy. The comprehensive nature of CSRD reporting is likely to elevate sustainability considerations in corporate decision-making.
- Evolving reporting standards. The European Sustainability Reporting Standards will likely continue to develop, reflecting emerging sustainability challenges and stakeholder expectations.
- Potential global influence. The CSRD could serve as a model for other regions, potentially leading to more harmonized global sustainability reporting standards.
- Enhanced stakeholder engagement. More comprehensive sustainability disclosures may facilitate deeper dialogue between companies and their stakeholders on sustainability issues.
Shaping a sustainable future
Implementing these policies requires commitment, strategic thinking, and, often, a cultural The CSRD is set to revolutionize sustainability reporting across the European Union and beyond.
From its emphasis on double materiality to its broad scope encompassing large companies, listed SMEs, and even non-EU entities with significant EU presence, the CSRD is poised to drive meaningful change in how businesses approach and communicate their sustainability efforts.
Leaders navigating this new directive can benefit from IMD’s transformative learning journey, “Driving Sustainability from the Boardroom“. This program immerses participants in real-world scenarios and case studies, providing a deep understanding of the complexities ESG brings to leadership roles.
Through engagement with diverse IMD faculty, guest speakers, and activists, participants gain broad perspectives on this multifaceted topic, equipping them with the insights and tools needed to lead in an era of heightened sustainability focus. Apply today!
Get the latest governance content in your inbox 💌